November 17, 2026 — A federal judge in Honolulu has thrown out the government’s finding that a seabed mining lease sale off American Samoa would not likely harm protected species, and the attorneys who won the case say Thursday’s auction should not go forward.
They say the same flaw runs through the approval for the Dec. 16 sale in the Marianas, where the closest lease area sits about 47 miles from Guam.
U.S. District Judge Jill Otake ruled in an order dated Monday that the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act when it cleared the sale. She granted summary judgment to Fa‘asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council for Hawai‘i and vacated the agency’s letter of concurrence.
“She wiped it out,” David Henkin, an Earthjustice attorney who represents both groups, told The Guam Daily Post on Tuesday.
The letter had concluded the sale was not likely to adversely affect listed species. Otake found the agency never seriously examined that question. It accepted the Marine Minerals Administration’s definition of the action as the sale itself plus some early survey work and omitted the mining the leases are meant to make possible. The judge described the “cramped, expedited, informal consultation” as apparently unprecedented for offshore leasing.
The record shows the agency issued its letter ten days after deciding it had enough information to begin the review.
